Sunday, 7 February 2010

Prospect archives

By Rob Staton
Apologies for the lack of detailed analysis from my end over the weekend. It's been a very busy week work-wise and this will likely continue through until Thursday. If I have some spare time I'll make sure I dedicate it to updating the blog. In the meantime, don't forget to check out the prospect archives page on the right hand side bar. I've tallied up the most of the articles I've written and put them into prospect specific sections. It'll stop me repeating myself too often in articles as I'll be able to refer to previous reports and topics. Don't forget if you ever have any questions, feel free to leave them in the comments section or email rob@seahawksdraftblog.com and I'll do my best to get back to you as soon as possible.

Saturday, 6 February 2010

POTD: Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska


By Kip Earlywine

Height: 6'4"
Weight: 305 lbs.
Unofficial 40: 5.00



Positives:

-Ridiculously powerful
-Very good hand use, disengages with extreme ease
-Has a knack for batting down passes
-Incredible 2009 production
-Is often totally unblockable, even by double teams
-Consistent
-Good combination of size/athleticism/effort
-Leader on the field
-Versatile

Negatives:

-Isn't super fast and probably has average quickness.
-Some knee injuries in his past
-Kind of a tweener
-Is stood up easily (plays with high leverage)
-Relies on brute strength to shed blockers more than skill

Sound bites:

"Suh is maybe the most dominating defensive tackle I've seen in 32 years of doing this."
-Mel Kiper jr.

My thoughts:

Suh is a monster who doesn't even seem to be slowed much by opposing offensive linemen. What might be the most unnerving thing about watching him is how he makes every dominating play look so effortless. Its almost as if he glides without resistance into the backfield almost at full speed, even when double teamed. If Suh stays healthy, he'll be at least an above average DT at the NFL level.

There are some worries with Suh. One is that he's a bit of an injury risk. Whoever takes him will have to worry about the chance that he could become the next Glen Dorsey. Another problem is that because he's so strong and dominant, he's never really had to develop pass rush moves and against elite NFL competition, its conceivable that he could be slowed down quite a bit. Finally, Suh is versatile, but that is also kind of a weakness. He's not a prototypical 4-3 pass rusher DT (doesn't have a lot of quickness or pass rush moves- his methods look like that of an elite pass rushing 1 tech). The problem with him being a 1 tech is that his leverage is pretty bad. Its not every day you see a DT dominate with such a high stance and lack of leverage, and in the NFL, he might not be able to continue doing that as well as he had been in college. Suh could play a 5 tech 3-4 DE pretty nicely, but ~$70 million is a lot to pay a 3-4 DE. Suh can play a lot of positions, but isn't really a perfect situation for any of them either.

Still, Brandon Mebane fell to the 3rd round because he was considered a tweener type, and the Seahawks turned him into an elite pass rushing 1 tech. Whoever drafts Suh, I'm sure they'll find a great use for him somewhere. If he stays healthy, he could continue to be a breathtakingly dominant force at the pro level. And unfortunately, he'll probably give Max Unger and the rest of us nightmares for the next 8 years.

Friday, 5 February 2010

Concerns with Russell Okung

By Rob Staton
Regular visitors to the blog will know I'm not totally convinced with Russell Okung (OT, Oklahoma State). Visit most mock drafts and they'll tell you he's a top five pick. I don't agree. At best, I would give him a late first round grade. Resident scout Kyle Rota echoed those sentiments when he scouted Okung. It surprised me to an extent that the big left tackle was receiving such universal approval elsewhere. However, some concerns on a national stage have been expressed. The Scouts Inc group published these thoughts on ESPN's Draft Blog:

"Okung gets good hand placement and shows sound footwork once he's engaged with defenders, so he rarely gets beaten once he gets his hands on the defender in either the running game or the passing game. There's also a lot to like about his tenacity, and he can be seen on film pancaking defensive ends and linebackers.

"However, there is reason to believe Okung won't be as effective in pass protection in the NFL. First, he is not as strong at the top of his pass set as teams would like, because at 6-foot-8 he struggles to sink his hips. More importantly, Okung does not appear to have elite foot speed, so his footwork will always have to be sound. He also lacks the agility and flexibility Anthony Davis has shown. A potential fall from the top 10 to the later portion of the first round could cost Okung a whole lot of money."
- Scouts Inc

I also think it's interesting they've referenced a potential rise by Charles Brown (OT, USC). I'm a big fan of the SoCal tackle and believe he'd be a great fit in Seattle's zone blocking scheme. He's under sized (not something that will put off Alex Gibbs) at around 290lbs, but he's had ample time since the end of 2009 to get above the 300lbs mark. His frame allows for some bulk, so it shouldn't affect his athleticism. Nice hand punch - something you don't often see from college prospects. He's aggressive and athletic, whilst showing good form getting to the second level.

Last year we saw another converted tight end shoot up draft boards after a good combine showing (Jason Smith). I'm not suggesting Brown will make a similar move, especially not as high as second overall. But if the Seahawks are thinking they need to take a left tackle early, even if Gibbs teams haven't in the past, Brown seems like the most obvious candidate to me. A good combine could push him into contention as a top fifteen pick.

Thursday, 4 February 2010

POTD: Joe Haden, CB, Florida


By Kip Earlywine

Height: 5'11"
Weight: 190 lbs.
Unofficial 40: 4.43



Positives:

-Excellent in man coverage
-Great ball skills, hands
-Looks like he has long arms (my speculation)
-Extremely good at tipping passes away
-Very athletic, can get high in the air when he jumps
-Fast
-Good blitzer
-Isn't short or lightweight
-High effort
-No significant injuries
-Consistent, proven
-Great leader on the field, good character off of it
-Nice stats in '09 (4 INTs, 3 Sacks). 34 passes defensed in 3 seasons.

Negatives:

-Misses a lot of tackles and generally struggles to wrap up.
-Lunges a lot when attempting to tackle, usually with bad results.
-Supposedly lacks instincts although he looked like he had good instincts to me.

Sound bites:

"Joe Haden is a very talented cornerback with a very well-rounded game, but some teams might be scared off by his lacking instincts, which is critical at the NFL level where pro receivers are great route runners. Haden's level of production and consistency will get him drafted in the top 15 picks. He is one of the better cornerback prospects in the last couple years."
-Matt McGuire (Walter Football)

While I was researching this post, I found a couple of nice write-ups on Haden that are worth checking out.

My thoughts:

I want to stress once again that the POTD series is not meant as a final word on a player nor as gospel. This report is only made off of highlight/lowlight videos and easily available information, and serves as a preview piece. I'm reiterating this because I think CB is one of the hardest positions to evaluate based on just highlights or from game tape. The CB is off the screen most of the time and we usually can't see them until the pass arrives to their receiver. Further, there was very little to judge Haden's press ability at the line or his ability to zone cover. Most of the time, he was playing 7-8 yards off the LOS and in man coverage.

I think Haden is a really exciting prospect in that some of his problems are coach-able. By doing more tackling drills, he could improve somewhat as a tackler, and it would be very easy to break him out of his habit of lunging at runners. I'm not sure I agree with McGuire about Haden's instincts, but McGuire knows much more about football than I do plus he actually broke down game tape, so I'll have to concede to him on that. Instincts probably can't be coached, and if his instincts suck that would be a bad thing for us since we run so much zone coverage (blech).

However, in a man system, Haden is a true stud. He's one of the best CBs I've seen at getting his hand cleanly between the WR's mitts and forcing tip-aways. He always seems to be tight on a WR, even on trick plays. Watching him play, he has all the good things about Jennings and Wilson rolled into one player. He's a precocious cover corner like Jennings, but with Wilson's athleticism, ball skills, blitzing ability, and confidence. That, plus Haden has a couple inches on either of those guys. A very common comparison to Haden is Darrelle Revis. Its important that the Seahawks vet Haden at the combine and test him for zone coverage skills. If he can manage to be at least passable, the Seahawks should put him on the short list of options at #6. The Seahawks need at least 1 CB this offseason in my opinion, and I seriously doubt Haden will fall to #14.

Note: You can hear an audible "aw s**t!" at 9:21. I love when that stuff slips through (nsfw) on sports broadcasts.

Wednesday, 3 February 2010

The strength of the draft

By Rob Staton
When I published my latest mock draft, a lot of people questioned why I had the Seahawks using both first round picks on the defensive line. Sure, it's one of the team's greatest needs - but there are many others too. The lack of investment in the offense through early draft picks, at least in comparison to the defense, is well publicised. Make no mistake, this franchise needs a long term answer at quarterback. It needs an injection of speed at receiver and running back -not to mention some pure playmaking quality. One of the greatest causes for complaint with the old regime was the Seahawks lack of high pick investment at offensive tackle with Walter Jones ageing.

Having two first round picks would, on paper, represent a perfect chance to invest in the offense. Unfortunately, the draft is a more complicated science than that.

In my opinion, the absolute greatest strength of the 2010 draft class is amongst the defensive line. It's not even close. It starts at the very top with two stunning tackle prospects in Ndamukong Suh and Gerald McCoy and transfers into great depth throughout round one. It coincides, funnilly enough, with a cluster of teams who will likely target the position. Of the top seventeen picks, you could probably place a defensive lineman as a logical choice with any team except Washington (who own other wordly Albert Haynesworth and impressive first year end Brian Orakpo).

Let's look at the options:

Defensive tackle

Ndamukong Suh (DT, Nebraska)
Capable of playing as a three technique in the 4-3 or a five technique in a 3-4 scheme, Suh enjoyed a dominant career with the Cornhuskers. Projected stock: Top three lock, potential first overall pick.

Gerald McCoy (DT, Oklahoma)
If Suh is 1a, then McCoy is 1b. Always in the backfield, whether it's rushing the passer or forcing a tackle for a loss, he's the prototype three technique. Projected stock: Top three lock, wouldn't surprise me if he even went ahead of Suh.

Dan Williams (DT, Tennessee)
Capable of playing both schemes, but the best option for 3-4 teams looking for someone to feature in the valuable nose tackle role. Projected stock: Top fifteen.

Brian Price (DT, UCLA)
Disruptive force through the middle, has a knack of breaking into the backfield. Notched seven sacks as a junior. Project stock: Top fifteen.

Lamarr Houston (DT, Texas)
Unbelievably flown under the radar despite a seven-sack season for the Longhorns. Superb in the BCS Championship. Projected stock: Top twenty-five.

Jared Odrick (DT, Penn State)
Versatile lineman capable of playing both schemes. Capable of playing the five technique in a 3-4 system. Projected stock: first round

Defensive end

Derrick Morgan (DE, Georgia Tech)
Relentless pass-rusher with a good edge rush. Prototype size for the 4-3 scheme. ACC defensive player of the year and the Yellow Jackets star this year. Projected stock: top ten

Jason Pierre-Paul (DE, USF)
Unlimited upside with extreme athleticism. Could be the most explosive pass rusher available. With the right coaching could be an elite talent, but concerns over whether he's a one-year wonder. Projected stock: top fifteen

Carlos Dunlap (DE, Florida)
Size and speed combination that draws comparisons to Mario Williams. Doesn't always put in 100% effort and character concerns after DUI before team's game of the year. Projected stock: top fifteen

Everson Griffen (DE, USC)
Hype never lived up to the production in SoCal, but he started to deliver towards the end of 2009. Stil developing, could see stock rise at combine. Projected stock: top twenty-five.

Brandon Graham (DE, Michigan)
Stand out prospect on a disappointing Wolverines outfit last year. Lacks size - that's a concern. Has a knack of getting to the quarterback and embarrassed Bryan Bulaga when they met. Projected stock: first round

There's a chance none of these prospects are likely to be around when Seattle picks at #40. There may, however, be some good options at receiver (Damian Williams), running back (Jahvid Best) and offensive tackle (Charles Brown). The chances of selecting either of the two latter positions early were potentially restricted following the appointment of Alex Gibbs to the coaching staff - someone who has consistently thrived in churning out a running game using a refined scheme as opposed to expensive draft picks.

Do the Seahawks need two defensive lineman? Brandon Mebane didn't have the expected success moving from the one technique to the three in 2009 and may be asked to switch positions this year. Colin Cole was unable to act as an effective force in is debut season in Seattle and looks like a suitable back-up or rotational player. Red Bryant has struggled to make an impact during his two years in the league (injuries playing a part) and Craig Terrell provides a unspectacular option in the rotation. Drafting a disruptive prospect like Brian Price to start alongside Mebane would draw a lot of interior attention, potentially making life easier off the edge for the defensive ends.

Having said that - there's room for improvement there too. Patrick Kernery's future is unclear. Will he be in Seattle next season? Darryl Tapp will likely stay as an restricted free agent, but has endured mixed success with the Seahawks. Lawrence Jackson likewise hasn't provided a reliable threat as a pass rusher and certainly is more effective sealing an edge against the run. The buzz word around the internet right now is 'elephant', or more specifically the ability of Tapp or even Aaron Curry to master this floating pass rusher used by Pete Carroll in his USC days. It's perhaps important to stress that for all Curry's physical qualities - he was never asked to rush the passer at Wake Forest and recorded a modest nine sacks in four years during his college career. Jim Mora and his staff last year likewise predominantly kept Curry in coverage, with mixed success. Finding an edge rush to pair with a greater interior presence could turn a definite weakness into a relative strength.

It's unlikely the Seahawks will fill every hole in one single draft, even with two early first round picks. A serious investment in the defensive line in round one fails to answer a lot of lasting questions on the offense. Clearly - that side of the ball requires some surgery and some love. However, with such a strong class of defensive lineman this year at the top of the board - you'd have to fight hard in certain circumstances not to take a double dip in this area. Methodically it might seem unlikely - but based on talent and taking the best prospect available on the board - it could make sense. At the end of the day, a better pass rush alone won't make the Seahawks contenders - but it's something that will need to happen at some stage.

Tuesday, 2 February 2010

POTD: Dez Bryant, WR, OSU


By Kip Earlywine

Height: 6'2"
Weight: 210
Unofficial 40: 4.54



Positives:

-Elite production (1480 yards and 19 TD's in 77 grabs in '08, 323 yards and 4 TDs in 3 games in '09)
-Solid combination of size and speed, not elite or rare, but still very good
-Good running instincts
-Plays marvelously well even when hurt, tough kid
-Solid kick returner
-Gets open
-Looks smooth
-If everything breaks right, he could be a #1 WR in the NFL, which very few WR can claim this year
-Is bulkier than he looks, he could probably add more weight if he wanted
-Has a nose for the endzone
-Awesome YPC (17.0 in '08, 19.0 in '09)

Negatives:

-A few injuries from time to time, including a knee injury at the end of '08
-Supposedly is a little immature, Deion Sanders incident, etc.
-Sometimes has trouble with drops and penalties
-Not explosive or if he is, it doesn't jump off the tape.
-Speed is sometimes underwhelming. Might not be a true deep threat.
-Came from a spread offense which probably inflated his stats somewhat and masks aspects of his game like beating a press
-Could stand to be more precise in routes
-Body catches a lot, but to be fair he does sometimes show good hands skills and come back for the ball.
-Because of good but not elite measurables, he's probably more likely to be a good #2 than a true #1.
-Not extremely physical, doesn't steamroll over tacklers and YAC could be better.

Sound Bites:

"If Dez pushes himself away from the dinner table and shows up ready to go, he's the best WR in this draft"
-Mike Mayock

"Going back to Crabtree versus Bryant, I think Bryant is a better overall player. I think he has better physical skills: he's big, he's strong, and of all the things he does, I think getting down the field and finding the ball over his shoulder... I think its a rare quality for a vertical receiver, he could easily be a top 10 pick."
-Todd McShay (on Sportscenter)

My thoughts:

Like McShay I see some similarities between Bryant and Crabtree. They have about the same size and speed, and both put up great numbers (including a ton of TDs) in spread offenses in the big 12. Another similarity is that in my opinion, Crabtree suffered unfairly from unsubstantiated claims that he was a "diva," while Bryant was the victim of a very strict NCAA who went over the top last year by suspending him for the whole season because of a meeting he had with Deion Sanders. I very much doubt that either Crabtree or Bryant have serious character concerns.

Of the two, I liked Crabtree more because he attacked the ball with his hands, had extremely few drops, and was incredibly clutch. Not to mention Crabtree was extremely difficult to tackle whereas Bryant looks fairly easy to bring down. If you wanted, you could call Bryant this year's Crabtree, although I'd say Crabtree was a little better, personally.

There are a lot of teams that will consider WR a big need in the first half of the 1st round, so for that reason, I don't expect Bryant to last until #14. Is he worth taking at #6? I would lean towards no, as he's not a superstar prospect. He's more Anquan Boldin than Larry Fitzgerald. I would personally prefer to trade into the 20's and get Damian Williams, but if the Seahawks draft Dez Bryant at #6, I'd be understanding. WR is a position that tends to take a couple years to acclimate to the NFL, and Housh, Branch, and Burleson probably won't be Seahawks more than 2 years from now. So it makes a lot of sense to address WR this offseason. If Carroll/Bates believe that Bryant will fit their system well enough to unlock his slim #1 potential, he'd be a worthy pick at #6.

Recommended reading

By Rob Staton
Chris Sullivan at Seahawk Addicts conducted a great interview with former scout Daniel Jeremiah today. Definitely recommended reading, Jeremiah is something of a twitter phenomena - you can follow him here. He offers some excellent insight having been part of the business with Baltimore and Cleveland. Of course, I disagree with his assessment of Russell Okung - but we'll not get into that now. Don't forget you can also follow Seahawks Draft Blog via twitter here.

Monday, 1 February 2010

POTD: Everson Griffen, DE, USC


By Kip Earlywine

Height: 6'3"
Weight: 278 lbs (some sites list him at 280, others 265)
Unofficial 40: 4.68



Positives:

-Versatile, can play both LDE and RDE and could probably transition to 3-4 DE.
-Smart player who usually makes the right decisions
-Good in coverage
-Solid vs. run
-Physical specimen who was highly sought out of high school
-Decent edge rush
-Rarely misses tackles, and sometimes his tackles have a nice "pop" to them.
-Good agility
-Stays healthy (missed 1 game I think from turf toe, that's it)
-No character concerns
-High effort, doesn't quit plays.
-Took a solid step forward in 2009 and still has more untapped potential

Negatives:


-Not a big repertoire of pass rush moves
-Doesn't have good hand use, has some trouble disengaging from OL
-Decent but not amazing production (7 sacks and 8.5 TFLs in '09, only 17 sacks and 20 TFL total in 36 career games)
-Looks slow sometimes, maybe turf toe?
-Never really blew me away... looks like a Ruskell 1st round pick.

Sound Bites:

"Griffen seems like a boom-or-bust prospect at the next level, and I'm not leaning towards "boom."
-Matt McGuire (Walterfootball)

“I think he can be solid. But to be honest, I think he’s a little overrated. I don’t see that explosion off the edge. … He should be a starter, but I’m not sure he’ll ever be a double-digit sack guy at the next level.”
-Todd McShay

My thoughts:


Griffen reminds me a lot of Lawrence Jackson. He's a well rounded, smart player, but his weakness is the area that matters most to a 4-3 DE, his pass rushing ability. Its not that Griffen sucks as a pass rusher, but he's very under-developed and if a player usually hasn't developed pass rush moves by the time they leave college, they probably never will. Griffen was not a major pass rush threat in college and I don't think he'll be one in the pros either. Griffen isn't a bad player, but the Seahawks shouldn't bother drafting a DE unless its a player who is a clear upgrade over Jackson or Tapp. For that reason, I hope the team avoids Griffen, especially in the 1st round.

Underclassmen invited to the combine

By Rob Staton
It was announced this week which underclassmen have been invited to the Combine (full list below). The event takes place between February 24th and March 2nd in Indianapolis. To see the group of seniors already invited, click here.

Quarterbacks
Sam Bradford (Oklahoma)
Levi Brown (Troy)
Jimmy Clausen (Notre Dame)
Jevan Snead (Ole Miss)

Running Backs
Jahvid Best (California)
Jonathan Dwyer (Georgia Tech)
Darius Marshall Marshall)
Ryan Mathews (Fresno State)
Joe McKnight (USC)
Shawnbrey McNeal (SMU)

Tight Ends
Jermaine Gresham (Oklahoma)
Rob Gronkowski (Arizona)
Aaron Hernandez (Florida)

Wide Receivers
Chris Bell (Norfolk State)
Arrelious Benn (Illinois)
Dezmon Briscoe (Kansas)
Antonio Brown (Central Michigan)
Dez Bryant (Oklahoma State)
Carlton Mitchell (South Florida)
Golden Tate (Notre Dame)
Demaryius Thomas (Georgia Tech)
Damian Williams (USC)
Mike Williams (Syracuse)

Offensive Linemen
OG Dorian Brooks (James Madison)
OT Bryan Bulaga (Iowa)
OT Bruce Campbell (Maryland)
OT Anthony Davis (Rutgers)
C Maurkice Pouncey (Florida)
OT Mike Tepper (Califorinia)

Defensive Linemen
DE Kevin Basped (Nevada)
DE Antonio Coleman (Auburn)
DE Carlos Dunlap (Florida)
DE Clifton Geathers (South Carolina)
DE Thaddeus Gibson (Ohio State)
DE Everson Griffen (USC)
DT Linval Joseph (East Carolina)
DT Gerald McCoy (Oklahoma)
DE Arthur Moats (James Madison)
DE Derrick Morgan (Georgia Tech)
DT Aleric Mullins (North Carolina)
DT Jeff Owens (Georgia)
DE Jason Pierre-Paul (South Florida)
DT Brian Price (UCLA)
DE E.J. Wilson (North Carolina)
DE Jason Worilds (Virginia Tech)

Linebackers
OLB Jason Beauchamp (UNLV)
OLB Navarro Bowman (Penn State)
ILB Donald Butler (Washington)
ILB Lee Campbell (Minnesota)
ILB Jamar Chaney (Mississippi State)
OLB Keenan Clayton (Oklahoma)
OLB Rennie Curran (Georgia)
OLB Cody Grimm (Virginia Tech)
ILB Josh Hull (Penn State)
ILB Rolando McClain (Alabama)

Defensive Backs
S Luciene Antoine (Oklahoma State)
S Eric Berry (Tennessee)
CB Cornelius Brown (UTEP)
S Morgan Burnett (Georgia Tech)
CB Crezdon Butler (Clemson)
CB Christian Chancellor (Clemson)
CB Dominique Franks (Oklahoma)
CB Joe Haden (Florida)
CB Kareem Jackson (Alabama)
S Chad Jones (LSU)
S Reshad Jones (Georgia)
CB Joshua Moore (Kansas State)
S Dennis Rogan (Tennessee)
S Earl Thomas (Texas)
CB Donovan Warren (Michigan)
S Major Wright (Florida)