Monday, 22 February 2010

Anthony Davis - Like a Box of Chocolates

By Kyle Rota
I’m not normally a big fan of writing these two game reports, as I don’t believe two games gives enough snaps to make a confident prediction on a player’s ability. Anthony Davis is a prospect who will require even more games than the usual 4 I aim for, but I only have two 2009 Rutgers games so I was forced to stop earlier than I’d like.

Two games is a nice number for one reason, though – they show us, in depth, what a guy can and does do on the field. That’s half the battle, the other half being how often he does it, and what he’ll be able to do at the NFL level. But the first half is important, and with the Anthony Davis rumor Rob wrote about (here) it seemed like a good time to write about the Rutgers tackle.

The first thing that stood out watching Davis is obviously his size and strength. He’s a good athlete, don’t get me wrong. Good enough to play LT in the NFL. But even more impressive is his size and strength. He’s 325lbs (or more) and he really does play like it. He really creates space for the running back on his side of the ball, and (in limited attempts) he does a good job getting to and removing the LB (a key part of zone blocking). While he is absolutely huge for a Gibbs-coached-player, he is every bit as athletic as Russell Okung in the running game and should have no problems in Seattle’s zone blocking system.

The one possible exception is cut blocking – given Davis’ strength advantage over almost every opponent, he had little desire to cut block opponents and I’ve only see him try at most one cut block (it was such a terrible attempt at a block I’m not sure what he was trying to do – sadly not the only time I was confused when watching Davis block). Cut blocking is very important in a Gibbs system, but it is also one of the easier skills to learn so it will be interesting to see (in other games) if Davis gets any opportunities to cut block. If he can’t or doesn’t, it will add yet another confusing issue for Seattle to deal with when deciding what grade to give Davis.

It takes a little longer to spot, but it becomes clear pretty early how inconsistent Davis is. You never know what you're going to get. I can talk about ten plays where Davis did a great job, and ten plays where Davis looked like he should’ve been riding the bench for Rutgers. Davis really impressed me with how he handled the speed George Selvie (USF, DE) brought to his rushes – Davis was able to handle Selvie with minimal help (something a lot of teams have been unable to do) while showing the lateral slide that makes me think he’s one of the rare players who has the athleticism to play LT at 325lbs in any system (Davis was standing up on most of the pass plays against Selvie, he’ll have to show the same athleticism with his hand on the ground as I watch more of him). He’s also (consistently, of all things) quick off the snap – so quick I actually thought he was cheating and beating the center, but really he’s just that quick. That’s an athleticism, instincts, and smarts skill all in one movement, and Davis really excelled there in the two games I broke down.

Unfortunately, Davis has also done some of the poorest blocking I’ve seen, from a technique perspective. There’s the time he launched himself a few feet off the ground at a LB’s general direction in what I am assuming was a terrible cut block. Or the time Davis thought blocking in the back (on a guy with no real chance to impact the play) was a good way to start a drive. Or when Davis flung his leg out in what was either a spasmodic movement or a poor attempt to trip the DE after getting beat, I’ll probably never know. It was really interesting on the few occasions when USF DE Jason Paul-Pierre was matched up against Davis, as you had two great athletes (JPP being more fast, Davis being more big) with terrible technique squaring off. Davis played very well against USF, but JPP was occasionally able to get pressure (Selvie struggled to even do that).

Inconsistency involves more than technique – Davis’s effort seems to grow and fade almost at random. He almost always starts each half playing with fire (sometimes too much so, as he is a walking penalty machine who I swear must be paying Big East officials not to flag him), but after the first series you see him mix great effort with poor effort, especially in the passing game – I think it is telling that some Cincinnati DE who I’ve never heard of was able to get two sacks on Davis, but the vaunted Selvie/JPP duo could not even touch the QB when lined up against Davis. We could be looking at either a motivation issue (playing up/down to competition across from him) or a conditioning issue (Cincinnati game was early in the year and he had to pass protect a lot due to the score, USF was much later, meaning Davis should be in better shape, and Rutgers was able to build a big lead and ran the ball much more frequently). Neither is good, but neither is unfixable either.

I can certainly understand why the Seahawks front office might be interested in Davis. He has the prototypical size and athleticism to play either tackle spot, flashes great nastiness and intensity, and gets off the ball quickly. However, the glaring inconsistency and poor technique really make me pause, as almost every nice thing I say about Davis has to be followed with “sometimes”. It is worth noting that the Shanahan Denver Broncos (with Jeremy Bates on staff) – who still ran Gibbs’ system, albeit without Gibbs – drafted a pretty similar prospect in Ryan Clady, who they coached up to be the best in the league. I can see the similarities between Clady and Davis, and it is certainly possible that the Seahawks are indeed giving the Rutgers tackle a long look.

Tebow working on his delivery

Sunday, 21 February 2010

POTD: Bryan Bulaga, T, Iowa


By Kip Earlywine

Height: 6'6"
Weight: 312
Unofficial 40: 5.02



Positives:

  • Good run blocker, really good when he stays low
  • Can get to linebackers FAST and blocks them well
  • Does a good job staying squared with pass rushers
  • Decently quick and usually handles inside moves well
  • Very polished overall, looks well coached
  • Plays smart
  • Hard worker (I've read)
  • Strong looking upper-body/arms, good hand use
  • Decently quick feet & churns feet well when run blocking
  • Very nice lateral step
  • ZBS experienced

Negatives:

  • Got owned by Brandon Graham, might be weak around the edge
  • A touch inconsistent, sometimes has bad games
  • Can be bull-rushed
  • Highest upside could be at right tackle
  • Not much room for growth
  • Short arms?
  • Missed 3 games with thyroid condition

Sound Bites:

"Bulaga still has room to improve in pass protection, but he displays the feet and balance to develop into a very good overall starting left tackle in the NFL."

-Todd McShay

My Thoughts:

A few times, I've had my initial impressions challenged when creating these POTD's. To this point, I think Bryan Bulaga represents the biggest 180 for me. All I had seen of him was his game against Michigan where he was owned for two sacks and should have given up 3 more... before halftime! Michigan was not a good team last year and at that time I was ignorant of the fact that this beating came at the hands of Brandon Graham, who is arguably the best pure pass rushing DE in the draft. Now, having watched the footage above and doing some research, I've come away highly impressed. Of all the tackles that are expected to be taken in the first 15 picks, I think Bulaga is the smartest pick for Seattle, by a mile. If you want a "big" ZBS left tackle, Bulaga is the guy.

What really changed my mind this time was noticing Bulaga's polish. There isn't a shred of awkwardness in his movement. His lateral step is quick and crisp. He squares pass rushers with ease, and like Anthony Davis, once he locks on, he wins. His arms aren't long but he uses them impressively regardless. His feet aren't super quick but they don't need to be because of good technique. Inside moves not owned by Brandon Graham rarely work on Bulaga. He usually dominates in the run game, but when he is occasionally stonewalled, Bulaga does a great job churning his feet to "win" the standoff. And when Bulaga raced to the 2nd level to engage linebackers, that was one of the few audible "wows" that escaped my lips doing this series. He's like a missile lined with Velcro.

As far as the bad things, that Bulaga was owned so badly by Graham makes me worry that he'll struggle with edge rushers, and NFL left tackles face edge rushers on a pretty regular basis. I noticed that Bulaga gives up a lot of ground on bull rushes. He doesn't get destroyed by them, but a defensive end is winning the battle if he forces a tackle into the QB less than 3 seconds after the snap. I wouldn't call the bull rush something to be exploited, but is an area he could improve at. Other than that, I really can't say many bad things about him. The thyroid condition adds some uncertainty. Remember when Engram had one of those? He missed a whole year, but then he came back and had the best year of his life.

The Big 10 is not the greatest BCS conference, but it's well known for producing NFL linemen (among them Rob Sims and Steve Hutchinson). Iowa is a well coached team that runs a variant of zone blocking scheme. Thanks to good coaching and practice, Bulaga excelled in this system despite his size, earning the Big Ten's 2009 offensive lineman of the year award.

Overall, I came away very impressed, and I now understand why Bulaga seemingly has been picking up momentum lately (McShay had him going #6 to us pretty recently). I think Bulaga will be off the board (deservingly) between picks 5-15. I think of all the tackle prospects I've seen so far, Bulaga has the best chance of coming in on day 1 and being a quality starter for a zone team. His upside is lower than Davis, Campbell, and Okung, but right now, I think he's the best combination of good player meets low risk. Even if he struggles at left tackle, he'd probably be one of the best right tackles in the league, and if moved to guard, he'd be a better version of Rob Sims. The Seahawks could use a right tackle, and even another guard, so pretty much no matter what, if drafted, Bulaga would be an asset to the Seahawks line for years to come.

NFL Combine week preview

By Rob Staton
It's the week of the scouting combine, as the NFL's focus of attention rests on Indianapolis from this Wednesday. The offensive lineman and tight ends get things under way on day one, followed by quarterbacks, receivers and running backs on day two. The defensive lineman and linebackers work out on March 1st and the event is complete when the defensive backs take part the day after.

It could be an interesting time for many reasons - especially with the trade window opening again three days after the combine - expect a lot of rumor and speculation as to what teams will be doing on March 5th. The big story is likely to be St. Louis and their situation at quarterback. This will be a chance for the Rams to speak to Sam Bradford and Jimmy Clausen, do some medical checks and get a feel for both prospects.

A lot of reports have been suggesting a strong interest in acquiring Michael Vick from the Eagles. Mike Sando at ESPN also suggests free agent Chad Pennington could be an option. I actually think that the Rams could draft a quarterback first overall and still bring in a Vick or Pennington. Let's be honest here, both of those prospects would be short term measures. If they want to draft someone like Bradford, this would give them the chance to bring him in and not feel the need to start him immediately. Alternatively, if the Rams do sign a quarterback elsewhere, a lot of assumptions will be made that they'll shift their attentions to Ndamukong Suh or Gerald McCoy. That could be true, but this is a quarterback league and the Rams will continue to go nowhere without a franchise signal caller.

Speaking of Suh and McCoy - the combine could provide an interesting battle ground for that pair. Suh has a lot of highlight reel plays including a superb one-man show against Texas at the end of 2009. McCoy hasn't got the youtube showcase, but watch Oklahoma and you'll regularly see him making plays in the backfield. Some, such as NFL.com's Mike Mayock, rank McCoy above Suh. The question is, who's game translates best to the pro's? Will McCoy's quickness and ability to penetrate through the middle create opportunities off the edge? Will Suh's ability to dominate college opponents with power and agility translate to the next level against more physical pro-lineman?

Some will prefer Suh and others, like Mayock, will prefer McCoy. If Suh runs as well as McCoy, shows similar quickness and burst in drills and shows the kind of strength we've seen in the college arena - for me there's little doubt that will be enough to satisfy those who maybe doubted Suh's status as the #1 overall prospect. However, if there's a marked difference between the two and McCoy out performs the Nebraska DT, you'll begin to hear a lot more debates as to who should go first between these two highly talented prospects.

There's always prospects who turn up at Indianapolis and light the place up - whilst propelling their draft stock in the process. Jason Pierre-Paul (DE, USF) is suddenly the darling of most mock drafts, with many pundits ranking him inside the top ten picks. I've had JPP in my top ten since January for the sole reason that this is a prospect with incredible athletic qualities. Some have drawn comparisons to DeMarcus Ware. He's got a great burst off the edge, he doesn't give up on plays and he finds ways to get to the quarterback. On the other hand, his run defense is decidedly poor and his technique needs refining. However, if he puts in an explosive performance at the combine - he could convince a lot of teams that he's worth the gamble. He might only have one year's production and he might not sail through the wonderlic - but there may not be a prospect in the 2010 class with JPP's ceiling.

It'll be interesting to see how the skill positions fare in Indianapolis. This isn't a great draft for top end wide outs and running backs, but there's some depth at receiver. Dez Bryant (WR, Oklahoma State) is a really intriguing prospect. What condition is he in after a year off? A good display could convince scouts about his work ethic after an extended break and solidify a top 10-15 grade. Can another wide receiver come to the party - Brandon LaFell (LSU), Arrelious Benn (Illinois) and even Mike Williams (Syracuse) could push their stock up quickly. Williams is an interesting prospect because he has serious character concerns but undoubted talent. Is he too much of a risk in the second round? He could quell some of those fears this week.

C.J. Spiller can do a lot for his stock. Teams love speed and Spiller has it in abundance. If he can run a super fast time in the 4.3's or even attempt to push closer to Chris Johnson's time in the 4.2's he could be a top ten pick. Some scouts will push him that high up the board especially after Johnson's tremendous season in 2009. However, if Spiller isn't as quick as you'd expect - perhaps running in the 4.4's - he might have to settle for a place in the teens. Likewise Jahvid Best - no doubt some will voice concern about his recent concussion and durability. Put in a performance in Indianapolis though, and suddenly he could find himself back in first round consideration.

Charles Brown is one of my favorite prospects in the 2010 class. He fits Seattle's zone blocking scheme perfectly and could be high on Pete Carroll's board after the two worked closely in SoCal. Other teams could be put off by his lack of size (approximately 290lbs) but if he shows up at the combine above the 300lbs mark and works out just as well, you're talking first round grade and a high one at that. Not many other prospects can do as much for their stock this week as Brown - he's a viable option at #14 with a good performance, but an indifferent display could mean he's still around at #40. Personally, I think he's right up there with the top offensive lineman in his class.

Cornerback will also be a position to keep an eye on. You can never have enough good corner's and teams at the back end of round one will give a long, hard look at some of the prospects available. Joe Haden is the clear #1 and could be a top ten pick. Kareem Jackson (Alabama), Kyle Wilson (Boise State), Devin McCourty (Rutgers), Dominique Franks (CB, Oklahoma), Jerome Murphy (USF) and Perrish Cox (Oklahoma State) all have potential late first/early second round consideration. Rutgers' McCourty says he expects to run a 4.3 in the forty yard dash - that always helps. Teams like speed and fluidity from their cornerbacks so this is a position that could be as competitive as they come in Indianapolis.

Friday, 19 February 2010

A quick thought about the Davis leak

By Kip Earlywine
One of my favorite things about the offseason is leaks like Chris Steuber's. We don't know if Steuber was fed these details to drum up hype or act as information warfare, or if Steuber legitimately uncovered it because the Hawks org was careless, or unaware, or unabashed. Either way, it definitely puts both Clausen and Davis officially on the radar.

I think by now everyone knows about Pete Carroll and Steve Sarkisian trying to recruit Jimmy Clausen when he came out of high school. USC also plays ND every year, so Carroll got to face Clausen first hand numerous times. Then of course you have the WCO pro-style offense. Whether you like Clausen or not, his appeal to Carroll is completely obvious. So when Steuber leaked Clausen's name, this shouldn't have shocked anyone.

With Davis, that was a little more surprising. For one, Davis is much better utilized in man scheme, and secondly, Alex Gibbs teams have only rarely drafted a 1st round tackle and when his teams have, they've never done it as high as #14 (nevermind 6th). So why did Davis' name come up?

If you think about it, it could still be a smokescreen. There may not be a better way to pass false information than to pair it with true information (Clausen). Adding to that is the fact that the Seahawks need a tackle and tackles are frequently top 10 picks who due to the value of the position are less likely to kill you with their rookie contracts. Pairing his name with Clausen's makes it seem very legitimate.

Davis may not fit zone, but he could still play the position for us. Last year, our two best OL (Sims, Spencer) were both guys with man-scheme talents. Davis is definitely a talented guy (albeit much, much more so in man).

In the end, the Seahawks sent out a pretty good smokescreen with Davis. They are either telling the truth, or its a pretty clever trick.

Chris Steuber: Seahawks eyeing a quarterback?

By Rob Staton
I contacted Chris Steuber from Scout.com this week to get his thoughts on how the Seahawks may be planning to use their first round picks. You can see Chris' latest mock draft by clicking here - he has Pete Carroll and co. taking Jimmy Clausen (QB, Notre Dame) and C.J. Spiller (RB, Clemson). So what is he hearing from Qwest Field?

"My sources tell me that the Seahawks front office is high on both (Jimmy) Clausen and (Anthony) Davis. Pete Carroll is very familiar with Clausen and even recruited him while he was in high school. He's comfortable with his abilities and knows what kind of player he can become. As far as Davis is concerned, the Seahawks view him as a young Walter Jones. Davis' size and athleticism are very intriguing. But from what I'm hearing the Seahawks are interested in a QB at No. 6 and will wait for an OT at No. 14 or in the second round." - Chris Steuber

In my latest mock draft I had the Seahawks passing on tackles early in round one to draft Charles Brown (OT, USC) at #40. A lot of people commented that they didn't think Brown would make it into round two. Personally, I'm a big fan of the SoCal left tackle. He fits Seattle's zone blocking scheme perfectly and has the kind of agility and smarts you'd usually expect from a tackle working in the Alex Gibbs' system. It wouldn't surprise me if he went in the mid-first round or earlier. If he shows up at the combine over 300lbs and performs well - he'll raise a few eyebrows.

However, is he's still in that 290lbs range he won't fit a lot of schemes. If other prospects fall at the tackle position, it could push Brown down the board. However, there's such a premium on the left tackle position it wouldn't surprise me if Brown found a way to stick in the first thirty-two picks. In fact, if Seattle want to guarantee a prospect like Brown - they might have to look at taking him at #14. Is that a reach? Not for me. I think he's talented enough, it's just the size will be an issue for most other teams. Tying up the blind side position for years to come - especially with an ideal fit like Brown - makes a lot of sense.

But back to the issue at hand - as Chris reports via his sources - the Seahawks absolutely should be thinking quarterback at #6 if they truly believe Jimmy Clausen is capable of making an offense tick. Tying up the most important position in football long term and not having to start him as a rookie is completely desirable. However, the big question is whether the team see Clausen or Sam Bradford for that matter as 'the guy'. Steuber's sources tend to suggests that could be the case.

POTD: Jason Pierre-Paul, DE, USF


By Kip Earlywine

Height: 6'6"
Weight: 263
Unofficial 40: 4.76



Positives:

  • Extreme athleticism
  • Size, frame, room for physical growth
  • Decent tackler
  • Decent edge rush
  • Fast off the snap
  • Played both sides of a 4-3 line
  • Lots of untapped potential
  • 16.5 TFL, which is pretty good for a 1st season

Negatives:

  • Extremely raw, very little experience
  • Limited pass rush repertoire
  • Mediocre hand use
  • Moves around like a basketball player
  • Slow feet, sometimes lacks quickness
  • Can be easily juked by mobile QB's
  • Highly questionable desire and motivation
  • Only 1 season of division I

Sound bites:

"Player Comparison: Gaines Adams. Forget that Adams was a bust in Tampa. This comparison has everything to do will the SKILL SET and JPP is exactly like Adams. Different intangibles could lead to a different career for JPP. "
-Matt McGuire (Walter Football)

My thoughts:

To be blunt, "JPP" is not a football player right now. Watching him play felt like watching a high school prospect. He almost looks like he's jogging when he runs, and while being 6'6" would make winning leverage difficult anyway, he seems content with running very tall. Another thing I noticed, when he runs, he seems to just have his arms flailing about randomly, which reminds me of a basketball player or high school football player.

To be honest, I'm pretty blown away that he has 16.5 TFL somehow. I don't see explosiveness, hustle, aggressiveness, or desire. Despite his amazing measurables and off the field athleticism, JPP never looked dominating on it and sometimes looked nonathletic amazingly enough. I was pretty shocked to see how many times players with far less athleticism ran around him with total ease or juked him out of his shoes. He also has undeveloped hand use and struggles to separate. Even his edge rush is not skilled- its just pure athleticism. JPP is the rawest 1st round defensive end prospect I think I've ever seen. Everson Griffen looks polished and skilled in comparison.

It turns out, there's a reason JPP looks like a basketball player out there. He was a basketball player through his junior year of high school. He played 1 year of high school football, then two years of JuCo college football (oddly enough, for two different junior colleges), before coming to one of the smallest BCS schools and playing 1 season of division I football. In a way, I really should be giving JPP a lot of credit for the stats he produced (including 6.5 sacks), because in terms of experience, he's the equivalent of a high school senior, and those kind of stats are pretty good for any first year division I player. I understand why JPP came out and financially, he obviously made the right decision, but I really wish he had spent another year in college to develop. Playing time is earned in the NFL and development can be difficult. JPP will likely struggle badly in his first 2-3 seasons. How long will an NFL team continue to give him painful reps for the sake of development? Defensive end is one of the slowest developing NFL defensive positions, and it regularly takes even very talented prospects 1-2 years to start playing well. Whoever drafts JPP, they are doomed for failure unless they are ridiculously patient.

Opinion of JPP will hinge upon the perception of his ability to develop. The NFL does not allow teams to draft players out of high school, but consider this the equivalent. The player JPP reminds me the most of is Jordan Kent. Kent was also a basketball player who attempted a very late conversion to football. Kent's size and athleticism gave him the potential of a true #1 WR, but at the end of the day, he completely lacked toughness, aggression, intangible skills and instincts, in other words- he just wasn't a football player. I see a lot of the same symptoms with JPP. That makes me pessimistic that he will reach his vast potential. If you disagree, he's a worthy top 25 pick.

Thursday, 18 February 2010

Kiper, McShay on receivers and Thursday links



Mel Kiper has updated his mock draft. You'll have to be an ESPN insider to see the full list - the Seahawks take Sam Bradford (QB, Oklahoma) at #6 and Everson Griffen (DE, USC) at #14. Having avoided the spread offense in SoCal for so long, would Pete Carroll really draft the spread's poster boy to guide his return to the NFL?

Mike Mayock runs through his top five (or should that be top seven?) offensive tackles. The usual names are on the list, but since his last compilation Charles Brown and Bruce Campbell have over taken Vladimir Ducasse.

The Sporting News reports that wide receiver Demaryius Thomas has broken his foot and will miss the NFL combine. It remains to be seen how this will affect his stock, but he was already a difficult prospect to judge coming from Georgia Tech's run heavy triple option offense.

Dez Bryant says the NCAA suspension that prevented him competing throughout most of 2009 was 'unfair'. Bryant: "I would tell the college players to be honest at all times, but at the same time I just feel like - I don't know - the NCAA, they're going to do whatever they want to do. I'm just going to leave it at that. I just feel like it was really unfair."

Chris Low writes that Ryan Mallet has broken his foot and will be out for 3-4 months. I'm a fan of Mallet's and believe he could be a high pick next year. This shouldn't affect him too much if everything heals sufficiently.

Len Pasquarelli reports that Ndamukong Suh will participate in all combine work outs next week. It'll be interesting to see how he compares to Gerald McCoy - especially in the speed drills. That's one area McCoy might have the edge.